Q: I did not quite understand the significance of the two pictures of cyclides alone. One you just say is a cyclide, OK. But the other is an order h^4 approximation to a cyclide? However, the Dupin cyclide is algebraically a degree 4 surface anyway...or have I misunderstood something? Perhaps these are surface splines of parametric order 4. Maybe I should have read the text. A: Surface splines have off-hand nothing to do with the implicit box-spline-based representation of the paper. Ie. I am separately working on parametric and implicit representations. The approximation order is to be understood as follows: p(x,y,z) = sum a_i M([x,y,z]-i) + O(h^4) That is the defining polynomial of degree 4 is captured except for some terms of total degree 4. These terms are, however, approximated to within a multiple of meshwidth^4 -- and the constant is so good in the example that we cannot visually distinguish. Only the theory tells us that we should be off by a bit. So my statement concerning reproducibility is conservative.