Chaudhuri: 2 Comments: Message formats are not clear Team1: 2 Comments: Does not cover other requirements beyond connections and searching Team2: 3.5 Comments: Covers most requirements. Team3: 3 Comments: Everything would be more clear if we could see the message formats outside of the explanations. Team4: 4.5 Comments: Very good explanation and explicit message formats. Team5: 2 Comments: Does not include message formats. Team7: 3.5 Comments: Covers most of the areas. We no longer contact our neighbors to reclaim our clients. Team8: 3.5 Comments: Provides explicit message formats. Chatroom leadership does not need to be transferred after a server dies. Team9: 3 Comments: Good description. Does not specify the format of the "Parameters" or "Message" fields inside the message. Team10: 4 Comments: Precisely describes message formats. Does not cover agent to server messages. Team11: 3.5 Comments: Good description of messages. Team12: 4 Comments: Clear and comprehensive message formats. We don't need to send user agent list to our neighbors. Team13: 3 Comments: Good description. We don't need to contact our neighbors to reclaim the clients. Team15: 3.5 Comments: Precise definition of message grammar. Users are not supposed to receive search results directly. Also does not cover client<->server communications.